Prometheus
The movie that follows the myth
I saw Prometheus on its opening weekend and now that I've taken a few day to think about it, it’s time for a review. After much soul seeking and introspection, I feel that the movie reflects the mythical Prometheus whom the ship was named after; he stole fire from the gods to give to humans and then provided liver sushi to a giant eagle for all eternity. I know Sir Ridley Scott was using this Greek myth to make a point about gaining knowledge too fast, but what ended up happening was a movie that repeatedly got holes torn into the plot and tried desperately to patch them up, only to have them ripped open over and over again. I will be as spoiler free as possible in this review, but be warned there may be some spoilage.
To start with, most of the problems I see with this movie stem from it being filmed to be in 3D. Anyone who knows me or my co-blogger Tony knows that we are harsh towards 3D movies. This isn’t because they aren’t good, but because there are so many things a film has to sacrifice to do “good” 3D. Because of that movies that would otherwise be amazing get plot twists replaced by flashy action scenes and gimmicks. Prometheus fell prey to this affliction. It was too light hearted in moments where it should have been darker and blatant in places it should have been vague, all to enable scenes that make “good” 3D. I think this whole movie would have been improved by thinking less of how cool it would look in 3D, and more about how it could tie plot points togeather to create good prequel or even just a good movie.
The other problem is that the movie is supposed to be both a prequel and a stand-alone movie, but manages to be neither. On one hand you know this is the same universe that Ridley Scott brought to life with the movie Alien, but Scott tried too hard to create a middle ground between a prequel and a new story line. Instead of being an amazing movie that answered the questions raised in Alien, created a plausible storyline leading into the Alien movies, and created its own stand-alone plot, that in the end created more questions than it answered and became a flashy, Gimmicky film. There were many parts where characters made leaps of logic that weren’t really grounded in logic, but served only to swing the plot the way it needed to go, and many scenes where a simpler string of events would have been a vast improvement, but instead it became drowned in 3D effects. The 5-minute blurb that served as the tie-in to Alien was pretty good, but it would have been better if it had taken over the movie in little hints here and there, rather than making a 3D bonanza and then remembering that it was supposed to be a prequel. Many characters where nothing more than fodder to create false tension.
All that being said, I really did enjoy this movie. It had really good acting, the special effects were gorgeous, the stunt work was top notch and the dialog was good. The only problem is that this movie didn't know what it wanted to be. On one hand, it could have been the perfect prequel with every duck in a row, but was ruined by the 3D affliction. Then on the other hand it could have spawned its own amazing series, complete with a new mythology, but because it was supposed to be a prequel it couldn’t do that either. Sir Scott, you should have just done one or the other, not ruined a good thing for "artistic" choices. (But thank you for this movie that shit was AWESOME.)
In the end we are left with a good movie that could have been a 10 out of 10, but was brought down by the ambition to make a gimmicks, instead of a good movie. I give it a 7 of 10, and Sir Scott can keep his nerd card. He has done way too many good movies to justify taking his card away, even if Prometheus could have been done WAY better.
(so the unedited version of this story was originally posted, here is the final edit)